The U.S. Supreme Court handed President Donald Trump a legal development this week, declining to revisit his dismissal of a Democratic appointee.The justices rejected an appeal from Gwynne Wilcox, a member of the National Labor Relations Board.Their decision leaves standing a lower court ruling that upheld Trump’s authority to remove her. The action could significantly matter for an unresolved dispute involving the National Credit Union Administration.Two former NCUA board members are challenging their dismissals. The dispute raises questions about who controls federal officials exercising government power.Wilcox was appointed to a five-year term by President Joe Biden in 2023.Trump removed her in January 2025, shortly after returning to the White House. Wilcox argued that federal law protected labor board members from dismissal without cause.A federal district judge initially agreed, upholding statutory protections. But a divided federal appeals court reversed that ruling.The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear Wilcox’s appeal leaves that appellate judgment undisturbed.Importantly, declining review does not itself constitute a new Supreme Court ruling on the underlying constitutional arguments.The justices did not explain why they rejected the appeal.In June, the court upheld Trump’s removal of FTC member Rebecca Slaughter.That decision overturned the precedent established in Humphrey’s Executor, from 1935. The earlier precedent had allowed Congress to protect certain independent regulators from removal.The newer ruling strengthened presidential removal authority. Supporters argue elected presidents must retain meaningful authority over executive branch personnel.Critics warn that expanded removal power could undermine regulatory independence. Wilcox expressed disappointment after the justices declined her request for review.She said the outcome affected workers and employers relying on impartial resolution of labor disputes.The Justice Department declined to comment on Monday’s decision.Meanwhile, a lawsuit remains active.Former NCUA board members Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka are contesting Trump’s April 2025 decision to remove them.Both were Democratic members of the agency’s governing board.
Supreme Court Rejects Agency Firing Appeal as NCUA Board Fight Continues
Views: 141